Reporter Jeffrey Kofman's ABC News report from Buras, La., on July 26 asked Where did all the crude go? Agence France-Presse (AFP) followed on July 27, asking Where is all the oil? An Associated Press headline that day asked Gulf Flow Has Stopped, But Where Is the Oil? By July 29, Times Michael Grunwald went even further, penning a story headlined The BP Spill: Has the Damage Been Exaggerated?, in which he wrote, But so far while its important to acknowledge that the long-term potential danger is simply unknowable for an underwater event that took place just three months ago it does not seem to be inflicting severe environmental damage.
The media stampede ignored a few salient facts. Coastal parishes last week all reported oil on shore or close to shore, or both. On July 28, the National Resources Defense Council issued a report showing 2,000 beach closings, advisories and notices had been issued in the Gulf region so far this year compared with 237 in all of 2009. Oil is also blowing through boom, landing along islands off the Mississippi and Louisiana coasts. More ominously, oil is billowing under the waters surface in large patches some stretching for miles and sinking rapidly, thanks to BP-applied dispersants. The controversial dispersants break oil apart and send it to the oceans floor or into plumes and currents, which can carry the oil thousands of miles from its source.
AFP reported the real difficulty now is finding any oil to clean up. National Incident Commander Thad Allen adds, What were trying to figure out is where is all the oil at and what can we do about it.
If the U.S. Coast Guard and other agencies cant find it, perhaps they dont know where to look.
Local blogger Jason Berry (aka Ashe Dambala, theamericanzombie.blogspot.com) flew over oil-impacted areas on July 23 and 26 and found oil right under his nose on the earlier flight. From New Orleans to Raccoon Island, to the Deepwater Horizon well, to Horn Island and to Ocean Springs, Miss., Berry photographed miles-long patches of dispersed oil and ribbons of crude. Just three days later, he says, the Gulf surface was noticeably clearer.
Theyre sinking the oil, and its sinking very quickly, Berry says. In just a couple days, theres little to no signs of it. That doesnt mean its not there.
Submerged oil, he says, is moving east of the Mississippi River like the Blob and breaks up as it approaches the coastline, spraying it with globules and tar balls. Meanwhile, Berry says, he observed children and families playing in the shallow waters along the beach. I want to tell those mothers, Do you have any idea whats sitting 100 yards that way? Berry says.
Berrys initial flyover in which he took dozens of photographs of oil-fouled waters occurred just two days before ABC News Kofman took a similar flight to the submerged rig and reported There was no oil to be seen. In response to a query, Kofman told Gambit the photographs of clean waters accompanying his story on the ABC News website were taken July 9 two weeks earlier.
Louisiana State University environmental studies professor Ed Overton told Kofman the disappearing oil is Mother Nature doing her job, noting that microbes and small marine organisms digest the broken-down oil. Is that a good thing? That impact may confirm some marine scientists greatest fears that once oil is embedded in the water column, affecting marine life in its most basic forms, it sets off a chain reaction in the food web.
Mother Jones human rights reporter Mac McClelland, in a post titled "Mainstream Media Helps BP Pretend There' s No Oil," says:
I sent one text message to Bloomberg's Lizzie O'Leary, who's standing on Grand Isle, Louisiana, right now, asking how the beach looks. "Lower part past the barrier untouched with globs of oil that washed up last night," she said. ... I sent another text to Drew Wheelan, who's also in Southwestern Louisiana, doing bird surveys for the American Birding Association, asking him how big the biggest tar mat on Grand Terre the scene of those now famous horrifying oiled-bird photos is. "20 feet by 15," he said. "But bigger ones submerged slightly."
If I managed to find that much oil with my BlackBerry without getting dressed or leaving the house, let's hope Thad Allen ... can locate some more with the staff and craft of the United States Coast Guard at his disposal.
Time's Grunwald whose piece gathered extensive quotes from federally appointed sources and, uh, Ivor van Heerden fired back at Mother Jones' Kate Sheppard, who criticized him for downplaying the disaster. In an email to Sheppard, Grunwald says the oil crisis is a drop in the bucket of much larger problem: dead zones and wetlands loss two things we obviously take very seriously to which BP has only added fuel to the fire. Funny, 'cause he doesn't exactly spell it out until he sends his rebuttal to the otherwise sunny Time piece:
... Its true that some scientists worry that the BP spill may lower dissolved oxygen levels. But so far, theres been only modest depletion nothing approaching hypoxia. Meanwhile, theres already a gigantic hypoxia problem in the Gulf. So what deserves wall-to-wall coverage: The actual environmental disaster of the Gulfs dead zone, or a potential environmental problem from the spill?